Cybersecurity Defense and Recovery Checklist for Bank and Credit Union Leaders

Innovation Circuit,

Sean Darragh, CSI

Share this checklist with leaders and board members to assess gaps in your organization’s preparedness to defend against and recover from a cybersecurity event. Review this list as you add tools and vendors, update technology policies, and welcome new leaders. Please note that serving specific industries or being subject to different regulations may lead to additional cybersecurity requirements beyond the items noted below. This checklist is intended for educational purposes and should only be used as a precursor for formal legal, compliance, and information security guidance.

Cybersecurity Defenses:

Governance and Risk 

  • Maintain a board-approved information security program and a defined cyber risk appetite 
  • Designate a management-level information security or technology staff member as a representative to the board 
  • Complete an enterprise cyber risk assessment annually and after major changes 
  • Maintain an AI governance policy and approved-use list, with oversight of AI tools 
  • Define incident severity levels and escalation paths 


Data Security 

  • Maintain an inventory of hardware, software, data, and critical systems 
  • Classify data by sensitivity and encrypt it at rest and in transit, with managed encryption keys 
  • Maintain tested offline or immutable data backups 
  • Test data restores regularly against defined recovery time and recovery point objectives (RTO/RPO) 
  • Complete a business impact analysis and align it with disaster recovery and business continuity plans 


Threat Monitoring 

  • Enable endpoint detection and response 
  • Implement continuous monitoring with centralized logging and defined log retention 
  • Provide 24/7 monitoring through a security operations center or managed detection and response service 
  • Patch security vulnerabilities on risk-based timelines (for example, critical patches within a set number of days) 
  • Scan for vulnerabilities regularly and retire end-of-life systems 
  • Participate in FS-ISAC or a similar threat intelligence-sharing group


Anti-Phishing/Email Security 

  • Create company-wide email filters with administrator-managed quarantine 
  • Enforce DMARC, SPF, and DKIM email authentication 
  • Use phishing-resistant multi-factor authentication (MFA) 


Access/Permissions 

  • Set least-privilege access for employees, contractors, and vendors 
  • Control and monitor privileged accounts with privileged access management 
  • Establish two levels of approvals for system access requests 


Network and Payment Security 

  • Segment networks and apply secure configuration baselines to systems 
  • Require dual authorization and call-back verification for wires, ACH, and payment changes to guard against business email compromise 


Vendor/Third-Party Risk 

  • Require vendors to disclose what data they access and how it’s used or shared, including with fourth parties 
  • Retain current copies of vendors’ cybersecurity policies, AI use policies, and cyber insurance policies 
  • Set terms within contracts requiring vendors to notify your organization of any cybersecurity breaches they experience 
  • Tier vendors by criticality and complete due diligence before contracting and annually for critical vendors 
  • Include right-to-audit, data-return, and exit-plan terms in vendor contracts 
  • Review vendors’ independent assurance reports (such as SOC 2) and assess concentration risk 
  • Include critical vendors in incident response exercises 


Employee Training 

  • Provide annual cybersecurity training for employees on topics such as phishing, AI-enabled fraud, social engineering, and ransomware 
  • Update training or add new training modules to address emerging threats 
  • Provide role-based training for executives, board members, and wire and payment staff 
  • Run phishing simulations and track results 


Independent Testing 

  • Assess vulnerabilities through an independent agency via white hat hacking or penetration testing annually 
  • Run tabletop exercises covering ransomware, third-party outage, and data theft scenarios 
  • Obtain an independent audit of the information security program 



Cybersecurity Recovery:

Cyber Insurance 

  • Maintain a cyber insurance policy that adequately covers the institution’s needs 
  • Review the cyber insurance policy annually to identify gaps and changes in coverage needs 


External Cybersecurity Expertise 

  • Partner with a contracted and trusted third-party cyber incident recovery team to expedite the response and recovery process 
  • Use forensic expertise to investigate the incident’s cause and document evidence for insurance claims and regulators 


Cybersecurity Incident Response Plan 

A well-documented cybersecurity incident response plan is reviewed at least annually and meets these criteria: 

  • Available offline and out-of-band (printed copies and an isolated repository outside the production network)  
  • List of clear triggers that should activate the cyber incident response plan 
  • Contact information for regulators and law enforcement, with notification deadlines (for example, U.S. 36-hour bank regulator rule, state breach laws, etc.) 
  • Contact information for legal counsel and cyber insurer 
  • Ransomware response plan, including a clear payment decision and maximum amount, OFAC/sanctions screening, and law enforcement notification  
  • Phone tree outlining who to alert first, including a back-up if the first contact isn’t available 
  • Communication plans for employees, business partners, and account holders 
  • Prioritized list of systems and platforms to recover at minimum viable capacity 
  • Containment and eradication steps, including criteria for taking systems offline 
  • Fraud and account takeover response and customer remediation (such as credit monitoring and card reissuance) 
  • Alternate channels and manual processes for critical services, such as payments 
  • Evidence preservation and chain-of-custody procedures 
  • Regular run-throughs of the cyber incident response plan with leadership, board members, and critical vendors 


Post-Recovery 

  • Validate that systems are clean before full restoration 
  • Debrief with leadership and key staff members involved in resolution to identify lessons learned and adjustments to the cyber incident response plan 
  • Track root-cause remediation with assigned owners and deadlines 
  • Update the incident response plan and report outcomes to the board 
  • Follow-up with regulators 
  • Close out insurance claims 

Read Full Article